top of page
< Back

Indigenous Stages

tahko-indigenousstages.png

tah-kōx

1

Volume

Active Presence: Spirit Characters as Cultural Sovereignty in Contemporary Native American Dramaturgy

By

Courtney Elkin Mohler

Published:

November 10, 2026

Featured Image: Hassett, Liz. "Production Still of Bad Medicine at Santa Fe Playhouse. From left, counter clockwise: Natalie Bennaly, Tara Moses, Isabel Contreras, and Ali Esmeralda Marin," <https://www.facebook.com/santafeplayhouse> August 26, 2026.


Abstract


A theatrically compelling element frequently found in contemporary plays by Indigenous North American playwrights is the presence of spirits, whose interactions with those characters in the earthly sphere heighten dramatic tension, offer spiritual guidance, and catalyze change within the world of the play. This article argues that such spirit characters exemplify Indigenous theatrical praxis by enacting cultural sovereignty, the right of a people to define and represent their own worldview. Drawing from my experience as development dramaturg on each work, I explore how spirit characters function in three plays: Desert Stories for Lost Girls by Lily Rushing (Genízaro), Yuchewahkehn by Vickie Ramirez (Tuscarora), and Bad Medicine by P.C. Verrone (Osage). In each, spirits arrive because colonial violence has opened a gap in the play’s world that only they can close, and each makes a particular demand of the living: action, witness, or reclamation. The Haudenosaunee trickster Bad Mind in Yuchewahkehn goads Myra Henhawk out of her apathy so that she can search for her missing sister. In Desert Stories, the ancestral spirit Placida compels her descendant Carrie Black to witness a buried history of Genízaro enslavement and sexual violence. The Osage Avengers call Veronne’s heroine, Aislin Alvarez, home to her heritage as a settler secret society seeks to consume the souls of Native people in her town. Each playwright draws on the specific cosmology of their nation and shapes it to the play’s genre, whether political comedy, poetic elegy, or horror. The essay closes with process guidelines for dramaturgs developing plays with spirit characters, grounded in trust, cultural humility, and the work of clarifying a play’s internal cosmological rules for collaborators and audiences.



My professional theatre practice is as a development dramaturg and director, working to support new plays by Indigenous artists. In this capacity, I have had the great fortune to spend hours thinking about the themes, aesthetics, and practices that particularize Indigenous theatre making.  I am interested in the tensions that exist between “drama” as a form, and “Indigenous theatrical praxis.” Specifically, I am fascinated by the ways aspects of Indigenous cosmologies permeate (and transform) scripts that are defined in part by their practical limitations such as duration, narrative structure, and individual character development.  Certainly, Indigenous peoples of North America have been telling and enacting dramatic stories since time immemorial, but my focus here is on contemporary scripted dramas, written with the goal of production. 

 

The following analysis comes from the vantage point of a participant-critic, as I had the distinct opportunity to serve as development dramaturg each of the three plays I discuss here: Yuchewahkenh (Bitter) by Vickie Ramirez (Tuscarora), which won the 2020 NNPN Smith Prize for Political Theatre and was produced in 2026 by Pool Plays 4.0 in New York City, Desert Stories for Lost Girls by Lily Rushing (Genízaro) which premiered in 2022 as a co-production of Native Voices and the Latino Theatre Company in Los Angeles, and Bad Medicine by P.C. Verrone (Osage), which opened in the first of its rolling world premiere engagements at Santa Fe Playhouse in August 2026.  In each, spirit characters are structurally necessary, emerging because colonial violence has opened a gap in the world of the play that only they can close, and each makes a particular demand of the living: action, witness, or reclamation. I close by offering practical guidance for dramaturgs developing plays with non-human, metaphysical spirit characters, grounded in trust, cultural humility, and commitment to support the playwright’s vision.

 

As a development dramaturg, I spend a great deal of time considering the spoken and unspoken rules of engagement that must be addressed when a writer wants to have their play produced.  A theatre company asks: to whom will this play appeal?  How will we cast it?  What will it cost to produce? And, before those considerations can even begin: What is the story “about”? and; will the company, cast, and audience “understand it?”  A theatrically compelling element frequently found in contemporary plays by Indigenous North American playwrights is the active presence of spirits, whose interactions with those characters in the earthly sphere heighten dramatic tension, offer spiritual guidance, and catalyze change within the world of the play. These spirits may enter the stage through possession of human characters. They may be heard via a voice over, or sensed through design elements.  They may appear as animal characters, gods, or ancestors.  And when they come, they may bring chaos or wisdom.  Inciting action for the human characters on the stage, they often extend Indigenous ways of knowing and relating to the world that, I believe, counter settler colonial dramatic aesthetics and structures. 

 

In this way, Indigenous spirit characters emerge as one example of what scholars have called cultural sovereignty.  Jolene Rickard calls for art criticism that can hold Indigeneity, colonization, decolonization, and sovereignty together, and she advances the term "visual sovereignty," linking it to Beverly Singer's "cultural sovereignty" and Karen Ohnesorge's "artistic sovereignty" (Rickard 83). Bridging these ideas is the claim that sovereignty is not only a legal or political status but is actively produced, the right of a people to define and represent their own worldview. Elizabeth Cook-Lynn grounds this argument most directly, tying sovereignty to the defense and practice of Indigenousness or tribally specific or pan-Indian religio-philosphical culture, law, and history (121). I find this framing useful for dramaturgical analysis because it shifts attention from what a play is about to what a play enacts. When a Native playwright puts a nation-specific spirit onstage and refuses to explain it away as metaphor or hallucination, the script itself becomes a site where Indigenous worldview is practiced.


Tuscarora playwright Vickie Ramirez draws on the Haudenosaunee spirit of Bad Mind to assist her main character, Myra Henhawk in her quest to locate her missing sister, Ellie.  The play moves between New York City and Aunt Hennie’s house in Lewiston, NY on the Tuscarora Reserve. Yuchewahkenh, the Tuscarora word for bitter, encapsulates Myra’s overall attitude at the start of the play.  Myra is a PR specialist at Decadence Media. She has just derailed a recorded Zoom land acknowledgment by offering her colleagues a Thanksgiving prayer of her own asking for reparations ("Rent is due!") and now faces a meeting with HR (8).  She is exhausted too by the performative wokeness she sees all around her, and expresses her bitter disbelief that activism is anything more than a never-ending circle of anger and pandering.  She “used to be activist,” like Ellie, but has been utterly burnt out by the effort (14). When Tyler, Ellie’s boyfriend, reminds her that change can’t happen when good people do nothing, she shrugs, “Who says I’m good people?” (14). When Myra learns that Ellie is missing, she must spring to action again, because her sister’s case receives none of the urgency it deserves in a system that registers missing Indigenous women as just another inevitable statistic. 

 

It is Bad Mind--the destructive and mischievous half of the creator/destroyer twin brothers in Haudenosaunee cosmology--who helps Myra to turn her rage, frustration, and bitterness into action. As a Trickster he needles, frustrates, taunts, and focuses her quest.  Bad Mind opens the play by directly addressing the audience, inviting them into this world as both grounded in the political reality for contemporary Indigenous women and also supported by traditional spirituality.[i] The stage directions read: “The Magical Realm is like Dark Matter. It weaves in and out of our reality.  Bad Mind controls the realm” (1). 

 

Indeed, Bad Mind is nearly omnipresent throughout the play; he claps his hands and we are able to see key moments in Myra’s past that help her discern her sister’s whereabouts; he also shapeshifts into playing various characters who frustrate Myra’s quest such as strict hospital administrator, a jaded police officer, and a slick corporate lawyer.  All of these shape-shifts are into characters who are not forthcoming with information that might help Myra find Ellie.  Bad Mind acts as a conductor or puppeteer at points, orchestrating events and dialogue.  He interacts directly with Myra and her aunt Hennie, who recognize him for the Trickster figure he is.  Their relationship with Bad Mind affirms their identity as Tuscarora, even though both women have complicated relationships with being Indigenous.  As I will discuss shortly, Myra's character arc moves from a guarded, self-protective distance from her Indigenous identity to  recognizing it as a form of power.

 

One of the most compelling aspects of Ramirez’ scripts, is her protagonists’ complexity.  As Myra digs into the mystery of what has happened to Ellie, she is forced to reckon with the reasons she gave up on activism herself.  She discovers that she allowed the constant struggle of fighting for change to defeat her. Instead of blaming the systemic patriarchy and racism that devalue Indigenous women’s lives, she blamed her Indigenous identity.  Ramirez threads this reckoning through the Haudenosaunee figure of “The Hand.”  In the last scene of Act One, Bad Mind claps his hands to reveal a memory of Ellie and Myra sitting on the couch, trading the traditional cautionary tales their mother told them as children.  Myra curls her fingers like a claw, “remember THE HAND!” The Hand, their mother told them, snatches naughty children away from their families, but it can never catch you if your toes are under the covers. Ellie remembers the lesson pointedly: "You told me it would make me invisible. Nothing could ever get me if my toes were covered at night" (43). The lesson they learned was that safety comes from not being seen. This is the same survival logic Hennie learned from her time at the Thomas Indian School, where children who spoke up were whipped, starved, or disappeared. Hennie has taught her nieces that "Little NDN girls who cause trouble get in trouble," and encourages them to "eyeball all the exits before deciding which way to run" (29). At the start of the play, Myra has fully internalized the Hand’s lesson, believing there is danger in visible Native identity. 

 

Bad Mind opens Act Two by stepping into the story himself, a glowing, clawed hand raised in the dark. In his telling, The Hand is no bogeyman for children who skip their chores. It is the machinery of settler colonialism, enforcing the boarding school mandate to "Kill the Indian, save the man!" and punishing any Native person who dares to ask "Why not? Why can't I?" (46). Its lesson is brutally simple: "a nosy NDN is a dead NDN. Myra understands that - Ellie didn't" (46). Myra's bitterness, then, is not about personal burnout, but instead a result having internalized the Hand's conviction that one must assimilate to be safe. Bad Mind scolds her, "You hate yourself, don't you?" "Always trying to fit in. To blend" (48). Then: "It doesn't matter how hard you try, Myra. The Hand will always find you" (48).  Assimilation and invisibility, Bad Mind insists, have never offered real protection from the violence faced by Indigenous women living in a settler colonial situation. If following the rules, attempting to blend in or disappear cannot keep her or her sister safe, the logic that has governed Myra’s life falls apart.

 

Myra's activation comes as she realizes that—although she and Ellie were both responsible young women—neither of them was ever truly safe. At Hennie's kitchen table she names the broken promise: "We did what we were supposed to do. Both got an education, and we both got jobs" (70). Hennie answers with the rule of The Hand: "You do your best, and sometimes they get you anyway" (71). Myra's reply marks her character's reversal: "I don't think I like that rule. I might have to cause a few problems and shout about it. . . . We have to get loud and proud. Otherwise, they can pretend that we don't exist" (71). From this point forward, Myra springs to action, and the scenarios Bad Mind stages for her become tests of her new resolve. The girl who learned to hide her toes now chooses visibility.

 

Only after he has seen this change in Myra’s character, does Bad Mind step out of his primary role as trickster-teacher, and decide to intervene in the major event of the story. Moved by the lack of justice and the colonial systems that do not serve his Haudenosaunee peoples, he stands over a hospital bed, in which a comatose Ellie sleeps and says:


The detective’s hands are tied because there’s no evidence of a crime. The organization she worked for had to worry about optics. Not Fair.  Cheating.  So it’s only fair if I cheat a little too.  Pretend you didn’t see this – it’s not something I do, usually.  But I think it would be funny, if we kick the system in the teeth and took a win for ourselves (87).  


Bad Mind touches Ellie’s forehead. She wakes. “Across the stage, Myra perks up” and says “Ellie?” (87). Through realistic dialogue and character relationships Bad Mind addresses relevant contemporary problems, but also deftly dramatizes traditional, nation-specific cosmology as present and effectual.


Reading of Yuchewahkénh (Bitter) by Vickie Ramirez, directed by Opalanietet. Produced by Eagle Project and The Martin E. Segal Theatre Center World Voices Festival, May 2026. Part of National Day of Theater Readings for Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Relatives (MMIWR). Actor in picture: Shaun-Taylor Corbitt. Photographer: Ash Marinaccio
Reading of Yuchewahkénh (Bitter) by Vickie Ramirez, directed by Opalanietet. Produced by Eagle Project and The Martin E. Segal Theatre Center World Voices Festival, May 2026. Part of National Day of Theater Readings for Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Relatives (MMIWR). Actor in picture: Shaun-Taylor Corbitt. Photographer: Ash Marinaccio

 

Ramirez’s play illustrates how ancient stories, traditional beliefs, and human-spirit relationships continue into the present. Like the people who keep these stories alive, Indigenous spirits adapt and transform so that the people may survive and thrive.   Maliseet scholar Bernard C. Perley describes the essential role that adaptable belief systems, rooted in Indigenous concepts of time and place, play in the survival of contemporary Indigenous peoples. He writes:


One unfortunate advantage of Western temporality is the ability to relegate ‘things in the past’ to immateriality in the present. . . . Those settler-colonial traumas are very much in the present for many Native Americans, and ‘getting over it’ will require settler-colonial peoples to recognize the violence their dismissal perpetuates.  However, a new cosmogony can bring both temporalities into an emergent alignment to illuminate mutually beneficial futures in the looming darkness of global self-defeat. (Perley 996–97)


Western temporality allows settler culture to treat colonial violence as finished, even as that violence remains part of daily life for Native people. Perley argues that an emergent cosmogony can hold both timeframes in view simultaneously. Yuchewahkenh dramatizes this worldview as Ramirez sends Bad Mind into a police station, political protest, and hospital room. The play’s given circumstances can only exist in the context of ongoing settler-colonialism, which chronically under-resources and mismanages cases pertaining to missing Indigenous women. Who better, Ramirez asks, to intervene in this miscarriage of justice than the infamous Haudenosaunee trickster spirit of Bad Mind?  His ability to shape-shift is ancient, but the active way he employs it to disrupt normalized systems of injustice within the world of the play exactly meets the needs of his people in this time and place.

 

There are innumerable ways that spirit characters or interactions might occur within an Indigenous script.  As a matter of professional best practices, the only responsible approach is specifically tailored to the singular story-world each playwright creates.  Ramirez’s depiction of Bad Mind is as a protagonist, a creative force whose machinations impact the human characters, creating conditions for them to achieve their objectives.  He intervenes in order for Myra to reconnect with aspects of her identity she had submerged. In Lily Rushing’s play, Desert Stories for Lost Girls, spirits contact the living because their souls need their surviving descendants to recognize how colonial trauma impacted their bloodline in order to find peace in the next realm.

 

Conquistador-inflicted sexual violence and forced conversion haunts the Genízaro people of New Mexico in Rushing’s Desert Stories for Lost Girls, which premiered in Los Angeles in 2022. This story metaphorically takes place inside of and at the edges beyond the sacred waters of Ojo Caliente. The ancient mineral springs, known by the Tewa as Posipopi (the Green Springs), and later named Ojo Caliente (Warm Eye) by the Spanish, are located roughly fifty miles north of Santa Fe, New Mexico. Since time immemorial, these hot pools have been known for their healing waters, which ancient Puebloan peoples recognized as a site for communicating with their ancestors, spirits, and deities. Bringing shells and turquoise offerings, they submerged into the sacred springs, edged with emerald algae-covered rocks, because these pools were the eye to the spirit world. Rushing’s play begins in Stockton, California, in the 2010s. Then moves through a kind of dream-spirit space into Ojo Caliente, New Mexico, in the 1930s and 1950s. In effect, the audience enter the sacred springs, as the contemporary characters are visited by spirits who have followed their progeny across decades and distance to be seen, felt, and known.


Cortes, Gretel. "Production Still of Desert Stories for Lost Girls" at Latino Theatre Company. (From left) Rainbow Dickerson, Carolyn Dunn, Samantha Bowling, Glen Stanton." 
Cortes, Gretel. "Production Still of Desert Stories for Lost Girls" at Latino Theatre Company. (From left) Rainbow Dickerson, Carolyn Dunn, Samantha Bowling, Glen Stanton." 

 

Desert Stories for Lost Girls shares the story of 18-year-old Carrie Black as she volunteers to care for her grandmother Rosa who is in cognitive and physical decline. As she bathes, feeds, and listens to Rosa’s seemingly non-sensical “bibble babble” (4), Carrie uncovers the secrets of her family line, which includes both Spanish conquistadores and Genízaro peoples. As historian Moises Gonzales describes:


In the far northern borderlands of the upper Río Grande, Genízaros were an ethnic assemblage of individuals and communities of Native peoples of mixed origins, mostly Apache, Navajo, Ute, Paiute, Kiowa, Comanche, and Pawnee. . . . Genízaros entered Spanish colonial society in the early eighteenth century as captives taken during frequent skirmishes with the numerous enemy “nations” that surrounded the upper Río Grande region. Some Pueblo groups such as the Hopi-Tewa of Abiquiú and others became Genízaro by displacement and relocation (Gonzales and Lamadrid 1–2).


Detribalized and torn from their Indigenous communities and cultures, Genízaros were allotted pieces of land strategically surrounding colonial cities and land grants, so that their own lives and livestock served as a barrier against raids from other Indigenous peoples. Even in times of “peace,” Genízaros were forced to work as the lowest caste in a foreign feudal system as indentured servants.  After slavery was formally outlawed in the newly annexed state of New Mexico, Spanish-speaking families continued to “rescue,” or “adopt” Genízaro children, who then performed hard labor in order to work off their “debt of peonage.” Denied knowledge of their ancestral customs and identity, Genízaros were subsumed into the bottom tier of Spanish, then Mexican, then US New Mexican society. Unfortunately, in a system based on dehumanizing notions of race and class, sexual and physical violence was prevalent and often inter-generational.

 

As Rosa’s mind begins to slip, she becomes increasingly agitated, tormented by her own memories as well as those which belonged to her ancestors. The fabric of Rosa’s reality stretches, becoming so translucent that she actually sees the spirit world; these apparitions are more than a memory and more than hallucination.  Their presence becomes visceral for the audience, as the spirit characters also interact with Rosa’s completely healthy and cogent granddaughter Carrie.  Both women seem to be accessing Scott Momaday’s image of an ancestral landscape that reverberates “like memory in the blood,” which Chadwick Allen read as a strategic assertion of Indigenous identity grounded in ancestry, land, and story rather than biology (7). In Rushing’s play, the memory that binds Carrie to her great-great-grandmother Placida travels not only through lineage but through the land—the soil—itself.

 

As if to welcome Carrie, a box of New Mexican dirt appears on Rosa’s stoop, while the ghostly Placida and Josefa spar in the backyard of Rosa’s small Stockton home. Rosa recognizes the dirt immediately:


ROSA. I know this.

CARRIE. Really? From where?

ROSA. Holy worm chow

HOLY CHOW

Ch maow

Chimayo (11)

 

Rosa struggles to form the word: Chimayó, one of the lands stolen by her Spanish ancestors from its Indigenous caretakers. Dirt is a central motif in this play, as it absorbs, reflects and maintains the time and trauma between the generations represented. Placida, an enslaved Indigenous woman, was raped by Carrie’s aristocratic Spanish great, great, grandfather Nicholas producing her son Manuel, Rosa’s father.  Josefa, Nicholas’ Spanish wife who was unable to have children of her own, stole Manuel from Placida to as raise as her own child, but always resented him as a “dirty” bastard, unworthy of his European blood and name (11). Josefa’s choice of “dirty” as an insult is pointedly ironic, revealing both her Eurocentric blindness to the sacredness of Indigenous soil and her disdain for Indigenous life.

 

Early in the play, Nicholas begins to torment Carrie in her dreams. He sees her as his property because she is his progeny; but claiming her brings no feelings of paternal love or connection.  During his lifetime, Nicholas was a conquistador who exploited the Indigenous peoples of Ojo to extract its natural resources to enrich himself. He valued the objects (women) and products (children) of his racialized and gendered violence in terms of his own wealth and power. Placida and Manuel were his possessions that helped him to create his legacy.  But, refusing to stay in her place, Placida led an uprising of exiled Genízaros against the Jacinto household, killing Nicholas and Josefa, and hanging their bodies from an oak tree. Her revenge came too late, however, to protect her own grandchildren, including Rosa, from Nicholas’ sexual abuse. Rosa later moved to California as a young pregnant wife, hoping to forget the ugly, tragic parts of her family history. But when she left, she was compelled to bring her Nicholas and Josefa’s bones with her and bury them in the backyard of her Stockton home. Decades later, their spirits are able to penetrate her psyche, altered and opened by dementia. 

 

These hauntings can only end when Carrie unearths what her grandmother buried. The bones must be returned to the earth of Ojo Caliente, and Carrie must remember the entire story, for the spirits to be released. Placida’s pursuit of her living descendants across state lines and generations sets a ceremony in motion that Carrie must carry to completion. Her digging summons Placida to settle her account with Nicholas a final time, after which Placida gathers Rosa and leads her home to New Mexico. The relationship between these ancestral spirits and Carrie is different from that of a mythic deity.  Through their familial bond, which extends past the bounds of their mortal life spans, they are able to demand her attention, but they also need something from her that they cannot accomplish alone. In exchange, Carrie gains self-knowledge: her passage into adulthood requires her to learn the truth of her heritage by literally facing the ghosts who give shape to her identity. “I know what I am too,” she tells us at the play’s close. “I am hers and hers and hers” (80).

 

Rushing’s use of spirit illuminates, and is illuminated by, the trope of a La Llorona. Josefa taunts Placida with the comparison during their first porch confrontation: “You’re like La Llorona, you know that? / Walking, wailing, looking for your dead babies” (11). She intends to insult Placida, framing her as a figure of grief and loss, a mother wandering and wailing for the ghosts of her dead children. Josefa uses it to diminish her, to cast her as a tragic, powerless figure defined entirely by what was taken from her. The resonances between La Llorona and Placida situate Desert Stories for Lost Girls within a Southwest cultural landscape where tortured female experience is deeply rooted in the legacy of Spanish conquest and the borderlands stretching north and south of the Rio Grande.[ii] However, Rushing evokes the trope in order to invert it by systematically refusing to collapse mythic sorrow with the specific injustice Placida and other Genízaro women experienced at the hands of sexual colonization and enslavement. The traditional La Llorona figure is defined by culpability, having drowned her own children, and by futility, condemned to wander endlessly in search of them.  Placida, however, is neither culpable nor futile. Her son, Manuel was a result of rape, then treated as property to be owned by her rapist.  Placida never abandoned or harmed Manuel, who was able to grow up, marry, and raise a family of his own, though he died indebted to the Jacinto household. In Rosa’s memory dream scenes, the audience learns that Placida broke the abusive reign of her Spanish captors by killing them. When Carrie unearths the buried bones for Rosa to return, she completes great, great, grandmother’s eternal objective. The play gives Placida the resolution that La Llorona is never permitted and indeed, her identity as a mother is affirmed as she assists her offspring deepen in self-knowledge.

 

Rushing’s play subverts the traditional trope of the living seeking out the dead for guidance, beneficence, and intercession.  Here, the spirits themselves actively haunt the living to ensure their stories are remembered. Carrie’s receptive presence is an act of restitution for Placida, who wandered, unremembered for decades. Placida’s ceremonial journey to repair—which depends on Carrie’s witnessing—is mirrored by the audience who bears witness to this Genízaro experience that Spanish, Mexican, and US New Mexican society each successively sought to bury. Placida’s words to Rosa might stand for the project of the whole play: “Not forgotten, found” (71). 

 

In Bad Medicine, three spirits of wind, thunder and rain, make a different demand entirely: they come to warn Verrone’s heroine, Aislin, of immediate danger, but she can only heed that warning if she can comprehend them within their specific cultural context.  Although she does not recognize them as such, Swallow, Dragonfly and Butterfly, known collectively as “the Avengers,” to the Osage, repeatedly appear to Aislin in her nightmares. Verrone sets Bad Medicine in present-day Proctor, Massachusetts, a fictional provincial New England hamlet defined by its colonial architecture and self-satisfied insularity. Aislin Alvarez, an Osage woman adopted at birth by a white Irish Catholic family from Boston, has arrived in this seemingly quaint town with her husband Cesar, a Laguna Pueblo professor of American History, following his appointment at the local university. Though Aislin holds a PhD in Indigenous Studies and has spent her academic life studying Native cultures in the abstract, she remains disconnected from her own specific Osage heritage. At the Proctor Museum of Natural History, where she works as a curator, she encounters Shannon, an Osage woman who invites her to connect with her tribe and learn its specific cultural traditions and wisdom. Meanwhile, their white neighbors Dawn and Erik, and the museum's director Theresa, belong to a secret society, “The Order,” whose appetite for Indigenous culture as personal commodity poses a threat that Aislin is, at first, unable to fully name or resist. Dawn, presenting herself as a natural healer and friend, supplies Aislin with a tincture of ostensibly Indigenous medicines that keep her drowsy, compliant, and increasingly cut off from her own perceptions. Although not revealed until late in the play, Dawn’s medicine in fact contains pharmacological drugs that interfere with Aislin’s birth control pills and result in her becoming pregnant. Over the course of the play, Aislin uncovers that The Order uses the museum to lure Native people to Proctor, where it freezes their bodies as artifacts in historical dioramas, while simultaneously stealing their aesthetics and spirituality. As Theresa explains near the end of the play, The Order uses the power of an ancient Viking Snake Knot to “absorb the souls of others” (88) and incorporate them into themselves. Veronne employs the infamous strategies associated with seafaring Vikings (dominance-through-violence-and-absorption) to heighten the danger in the fictional world of the play, and to underscore how the appropriation of Indigenous culture occurs at the expense of living Indigenous peoples.[iii]

 

While the supernatural forces behind the Order and the Viking Snake Knot emerge slowly and in step with Aislin’s increasingly paranoia, Verrone introduces the Avengers in the play’s first moments.  The Avengers surround a sleeping Aislin, setting up the motif of their attending her nightmares.  The opening stage directions read:


Lights illuminate AISLIN ALVAREZ sitting on a box, her eyes closed, dreaming.  A bundle of sage lies smoldering in a bowl beside her.  Behind her, the Avengers (SWALLOW, DRAGONFLY, and BUTTERFLY) emerge out of the darkness. . . . They raise their arms and beat their wings, surrounding Aislin. (1)


The audience encounters these spirits before they know anything about the play’s world, or the given circumstances of its human characters. In this way, Verrone establishes their presence as the primary frame through which we will understand Aislin's story before the realistic action even begins.  Unlike Ramirez’s characters Myra and Hennie, who hold the Tuscarora knowledge necessary to recognize Bad Mind and his machinations, Aislin was raised away from her people and did not learn that she was Osage until she was an adult. Because she was adopted into a white family, everything she knows about being Indigenous has come from her academic studies or from her husband. The play centers Aislin’s character arc so that the audience comes to understand who the Avengers are and what they want only as Aislin does. Initially appearing as frightening manifestations of her anxieties and insecurities, masked and inhuman, the Avengers not only accompany her nightmares, but also bring Aislin sudden, debilitating migraines. It is only by the play's end, and with the help of Shannon's mother, an Osage elder, that Aislin pieces together that what she mistook for sinister was in fact protective. 

 

The Avengers function in Bad Medicine in two overlapping ways: first, they act as a warning and exposure system, alerting Aislin to the dangers in Proctor; second, they are agents of reconnection, calling Aislin “home” by demanding she discover her Osage roots. This second function is similar to that of the hauntings in Desert Stories for Lost Girls, as the spirit world risks contact in order to make the living discover their Indigeneity. The Avengers call Aislin to engage with Osage knowledge that she does not have, creating dramaturgical suspense as Aislin misinterprets these visitations as terrifying; the audience does not know why these non-human spirits ominously demand that Aislin to “Open!” nor why they seem to torture her with snake imagery, movement, and sounds.  In the play’s second act, Cesar tells Aislin that he has looked up a word he keeps hearing her say in her sleep “Wets’a”:

 

AISLIN. Oh, It’s probably just gibberish.

CESAR. It’s not gibberish. It’s Osage. It’s the Osage word for ‘snake’ – though, the literal translation is ‘He Who Kills’ (57).


That Cesar must translate the word for her underscores how fully Aislin has been severed from her own cultural inheritance: she has been haunted by an Osage word, spoken by Osage spirits, without the linguistic framework to recognize it as such. This is the first moment in which Aislin, and by extension the audience, understands that the Avengers are specifically Osage in origin.


The Avengers hiss: “We watch, but Wets’a moves. The Serpent has swallowed the River,” Swallow warns (41). And later, Butterfly says, “We show you the rattle so you may evade the fangs” (62). Verrone then draws a precise dramatic correlation between settler colonial violence and Indigenous peoples' access to their own spiritual knowledge by mapping Aislin's disconnection onto chemical sedation. The Avengers can penetrate her consciousness only when Dawn's tincture wears off; each time Aislin drinks it, they recede in her perception, a dynamic the stage directions make literal as “the medicine kicks in” and “Swallow, Butterfly, and Dragonfly fade away” (70). The tincture is Dawn's instrument for keeping Aislin spiritually incapacitated while The Order extracts what it wants from her body: a baby “with perfectly good Indian blood” (89). In this way, the “bad medicine” can be read as a dramatic metaphor for colonial harm; Indigenous people’s disconnection from their own spiritual and cultural traditions is actively produced and maintained by settler colonial mechanisms. Dawn has profited from her fascination and misuse of Indigenous traditional medicines; Erik makes his living from appropriating Southwest Native American aesthetic motifs and selling them as his original work; Theresa, in her leadership position at the Proctor Museum, and the town of Proctor itself, whose economy relies on tourism and its relationship with its colonial past, all benefit from capturing and exploiting certain ideas about Indigenous people and history.

 

After Cesar translates the Osage word “Wets’a” from her nightmares, Aislin begins to piece together the truth about The Order, the Avengers’ warnings become legible for the first time. Learning this bit of original language inspires her to call Shannon’s mother, Mrs. Raynes, in Pawhuska, Oklahoma who can put the warning into cultural context for her.  Mrs. Raynes tells her that she had learned that the Avengers, “had the power to see what was hidden, and they’d dog you to the ends of the earth until you open your eyes to see truth” (82).  But, she explains, “you have to reach out (to your people) to understand them” (83). Here, Aislin realizes that these visions should not be avoided or muted through medication, and recognizes them as her Osage spiritual inheritance.  While the horror genre's final girl confronts evil alone, Aislin never does: the Avengers have been with her from the beginning and serve as cultural connectors. What distinguishes her from her secular counterparts is that her capacity to fight back is inseparable from her cultural reclamation.

 

Ramirez, Rushing, and Verrone each write spirit characters whose presence is activated by colonial harm, serving a dramaturgical function that resists the erasure that harm produces. Bad Mind intervenes in a world where jurisdictional gaps and institutional indifferences allow Indigenous women to disappear without consequence. Placida, Nicolas and Josefa pursue their descendants because their complex story of sexual violence, forced erasure, and violent resistance must be remembered and their bones must be buried with ceremony. The Avengers persist across Aislin's lifetime because colonial forces, external and internalized, have kept her severed from the Osage identity and knowledge that would empower her. In each case, the spirits are necessary to the dramatic structure of the world of the plays.  The spirit characters dramaturgically decolonize as their actions close the gaping holes—racism, historical erasure, and fear of cultural inheritance—all created by colonial violence.

 

Yet what is equally striking across these three plays is how differently the spirits operate, each working within culturally specific modalities and in response to the particular genre demands of their respective plays. Bad Mind's trickster energy serves the dark comedy and political urgency of Yuchewahkenh (Bitter). Placida's ceremonial persistence suits the elegiac, memory-saturated landscape of Desert Stories for Lost Girls. The Avengers' ominous warnings are perfectly calibrated to the horror register of Bad Medicine. These three dramaturgical models of spirit illustrate that Indigenous playwrights are not drawing on a monolithic spiritual tradition but on the specific cosmological inheritance of their own nations, shaped to meet the needs of the story at hand. In each case, the result is a theatrical praxis that is specifically Indigenous, by virtue of the worldviews these plays enact. I have written elsewhere about how Indigenous theatrical praxis may foster alternative modes of empowerment and work to decolonize.[iv] There is not a single playbook for such decolonial efforts, but certain creative impulses frequently emerge in new Native plays. This essay has explored how three contemporary playwrights draw from their respective wells of spiritual and mythic traditions, transcending normative Western dramaturgy in order to reflect and empower Indigenous worldviews.

 

Spirits as elements of drama must be culturally specific, and therefore are different than invented ghost stories or magic realism that may have a creative genesis tied to how an individual dramatist interprets the rules of an established literary or dramatic genre. This is a specific problem for dramaturgs working with Indigenous playwrights because, while the playwright does have agency in how they dramatize the spirits in their fictional plays, their choices are often tethered to cultural realities (worldview, knowledges, etc.) that require a degree of cultural protocol. To meet this challenge that I have developed the following process guidelines and offer them here as one approach to respectfully approaching spirit in Indigenous dramaturgy.


My methodology begins where any good dramaturgical relationship must: with the establishment of trust and reciprocal respect. In an initial read, I attend first to my own emotional and intellectual investment in the work, asking myself what draws me to it and where I feel uncertainty or resistance. In a first meeting with the playwright, rather than arriving with a list of questions or observations, I begin by sharing what I love about the play and asking the playwright what they love about it: what inspired it, what they consider its strengths, and where they feel there is work still to be done. Trust must be built, as it is the foundation on which every subsequent conversation depends.


From that foundation, I move into careful attention to cultural specificity. I ask the playwright to tell me about the world they are writing, and I share my own position openly: a person of Chumash and white heritage from Santa Barbara, CA, trained primarily in a Western theatrical tradition, working as a professor, director, and dramaturg. I ask how they would like me to refer to their non-human characters, whether words like cosmology, gods, or spirit feel accurate, and whether they are comfortable with me sharing observations and asking questions about the spiritual reality, stories, and values embedded in the work. My goal is to establish the terms of engagement that make genuine collaboration possible, while respecting that I am visitor in their story and process.


The third area of my methodology concerns legibility: how the world of the play and its cosmological logic can be made accessible to wider audiences, including settler colonial and non-Native audiences, without compromising its cultural integrity. I work with the playwright to establish who their target audience is, and what emotional, spiritual, political, and intellectual response they hope to provoke. I ask whether there are elders or cultural knowledge keepers whose perspectives have shaped the work and whether it would be appropriate for me to be in contact with them, so that their knowledge can be communicated accurately to the cast and creative team. Most practically, I work to clarify the internal rules of the play's world, the cosmological framework that must remain consistent in order for the culture and the story to be legible, especially when that framework operates outside Western theatrical conventions of realism. Identifying those rules is among the most important contributions a dramaturg can make to this kind of work. This is also a potential area for collaborators to unwittingly discount or disparage the work of the playwright. Settler colonial logics haunt the entire history of the American theatre industrial complex.  It is critical that the dramaturg serves as the buffer between designers, directors, actors, and producers who don’t yet understand the specific reality explored in this play. The dramaturg must anticipate the questions that will arise, and help the playwright to clarify these rules through the text as early in the process as possible. 

Across these three plays discussed throughout this essay, spirit characters emerge not as theatrical flourishes or departures from realism but as structurally necessary presences whose dramaturgical function is inseparable from the cultural and political work the plays perform. Bad Mind, Placida, and the Avengers each arrive in response to a specific colonial harm, and each demand something particular from the living: action, witness, or cultural reclamation. That these demands are calibrated to the cosmological inheritance of distinct Native nations, and shaped to meet the genre needs of their respective plays, speaks to the sophistication and specificity of contemporary Indigenous dramaturgy. These spirits are particular, tribally rooted, and dramatically purposeful.


For the development dramaturg, this specificity is both the challenge and the gift. It requires a methodology grounded in trust, cultural humility, and a willingness to follow the playwright's lead into worldviews that may operate outside Western theatrical convention.  Developing Spirit characters demands the dramaturg to understand her role as a collaborator in making space for the play's full complexity to be witnessed. The plays of Ramirez, Rushing, and Verrone, and the worldviews they enact on stage, are examples of artistic cultural sovereignty in practice. To work on them with rigor and attentiveness is to participate, however modestly, in that act of sovereignty.



Image Credits:

​

Article

Notes


[i] For a detailed exploration of Haudenosaunee cosmology, see Adams.


[ii] Like all mythic figures, La Llorona’s exact origins is perennially debated.  Luis Leal points to significant historical and archeological evidence that this myth has pre-colonial roots, but also concedes that key aspects of the figure we call La Llorona today materialized in response to Spanish colonial rule. As Alicia Gaspar de Alba writes in “Malinchista, a Myth Revised,” “It is a traditional belief that La Malinche – Aztec interpreter and mistress of Cortés- betrayed her own people in exchange for new life” (4). Leal writes that the contemporary conflation of the La Llorona/La Malinche figures “has been presented in contemporary Mexican and Chicano popular cultures, associating it to the trauma of the Conquest and the creation of the mestizo race” (134). In other words, the La Llorona, her meaning and her power have shifted to speak to the anxieties and concerns of her people over time.


[iii] Verrone draws on the Vikings’ popular reputation rather than their history. Caitlin Ellis traces that reputation largely to “history written by the victims,” the monastic chroniclers whose communities suffered the raids (2), and notes that the Nazi appropriation of Norse symbols further cemented the modern link between Vikings and violence (7). The Order inherits both legacies.


[iv] I argue that Indigenous theatrical praxis “can be achieved through (1) exposing popularly accepted racial and ethnic stereotypes as identity constructions; (2) rewriting history in a manner that repositions historically marginalized and objectified cultures as active subjects; (3) utilizing residual creative energies that transcend the normative methods for ‘art making’ thereby exposing an alternative indigenous worldview; and (4) destabilizing historical ‘facts’ that constitute an essence of ‘timelessness’ and edifice of authority for neocolonial and imperialist practices” (245).


References


Adams, Amber Meadow. “Yotsi’tsishon and the Language of the Seed in the Haudenosaunee Story of Earth’s Creation.” English Language Notes, vol. 58, no. 1, Apr. 2020, pp. 111–31.


Allen, Chadwick. “Blood (and) Memory.” American Literature, vol. 71, no. 1, 1999, pp. 93–116. JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/2902590.


Cook-Lynn, Elizabeth. New Indians, Old Wars. U of Illinois P, 2007.

Ellis, Caitlin. “Remembering the Vikings: Violence, Institutional Memory and the Instruments of History.” History Compass, vol. 19, no. 1, 2021, e12644, https://doi.org/10.1111/hic3.12644.


Gaspar de Alba, Alicia. “Malinchista, a Myth Revised.” Feminism, Nation and Myth: La Malinche, edited by Rolando Romero and Amanda Nolacea Harris, Arte Público Press, 2005, pp. 4–5.


Gonzales, Moises, and Enrique R. Lamadrid, editors. Nación Genízara: Ethnogenesis, Place, and Identity in New Mexico. U of New Mexico P, 2019.


Leal, Luis. “The Malinche-Llorona Dichotomy: The Evolution of a Myth.” Feminism, Nation and Myth: La Malinche, edited by Rolando Romero and Amanda Nolacea Harris, Arte Público Press, 2005, pp. 134–38.


Mohler, Courtney Elkin. “‘We Are Not Guilty!’: The Creation of an Indigenous Theatrical Praxis.” American Indian Performing Arts: Critical Directions, edited by Hanay Geiogamah and Jaye T. Darby, UCLA American Indian Studies Center, 2009, pp. 243-74.

Momaday, N. Scott. The Way to Rainy Mountain. U of New Mexico P, 1969.


Ohnesorge, Karen. “Uneasy Terrain: Image, Text, Landscape, and Contemporary Indigenous Artists in the United States.” American Indian Quarterly, vol. 32, no. 1, 2008, pp. 43–69.


Perley, Bernard C. “Indigenous Translocality: Emergent Cosmogonies in the New World Order.” Theory & Event, vol. 23, no. 4, 2020, pp. 977–1003.


Ramirez, Vickie. Yuchewahkenh (Bitter). Fourth draft, 2025. Unpublished manuscript.

Rickard, Jolene. “Diversifying Sovereignty and the Reception of Indigenous Art.” Art Journal, vol. 76, no. 2, 2017, pp. 81–84. JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/45142474.


Rushing, Lily. Desert Stories for Lost Girls. Sept. 2022 version. Unpublished manuscript.

Singer, Beverly R. Wiping the War Paint off the Lens: Native American Film and Video. U of Minnesota P, 2001.


Verrone, P. C. Bad Medicine. July 2026 draft. Unpublished manuscript.

 


References

About the author(s)

Courtney Elkin Mohler is Associate Professor and Chair of Theatre at Boston College. As a stage director and dramaturg, Mohler concentrates on works that push aesthetic and political boundaries and is dedicated to supporting new plays by Native American playwrights. Some recent dramaturgy credits include Bad Medicine by P.C. Verrone (Santa Fe Playhouse), Antíkoni (Native Voices), and Pure Native by Vickie Ramirez (Geva Theatre). She has published articles in Theatre Topics, Modern Drama, Text and Presentation, Platform, and Ecumenica, and has contributed chapters to numerous edited anthologies. She co-authored Critical Companion to Native American and First Nations Theatre and Performance: Indigenous Spaces (2020, Bloomsbury-Methuen Press) with Jaye T. Darby and Christy Stanlake and co-edited The Methuen Anthology of Native American Plays: Indigenous Spaces (2026, Bloomsbury-Methuen Press) with Christy Stanlake. Mohler holds a doctorate in Critical Studies in Theatre from UCLA.

Indigenous Stages

tahko-indigenousstages.png

tah-kōx

INDIGENOUS STAGES is the first global forum and interdisciplinary academic journal primarily dedicated to Indigenous authors writing about the theatrical and cultural performance of Indigenous artists and communities from across the globe. This journal will be the first forum ever for the diverse range of Indigenous scholarship and cultural performance practices not only to be shared among Indigenous communities but also to be published in English, or in the respective Indigenous languages with an English translation. ​

​

Published by The Martin E. Segal Theatre Center at The Graduate Center at CUNY, the mission of INDIGENOUS STAGES is to foster, survey, and publish the contemporary and historical theoretical discourse surrounding the field. Peer-reviewed articles as well as critical book and performance reviews will contribute to further strengthen Indigenous studies as an academic discipline within theatre and performance studies. INDIGENOUS STAGES will enable academics, students, artists, cultural practitioners, activists, and community members to research, discuss, and present their work in a unique forum—while creating and nurturing local, national, and global relationships within and between Indigenous communities and thereby fostering solidarity.

​

Published by The Martin E. Segal Theatre Center at The Graduate Center at CUNY, with additional support for the content of the inaugural edition provided by the Hawai'ian Theatre Program at the University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa.

​

Entries under this journal are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International license.​​

The Segal Center.png
file163.jpg

Table of Contents 

Previous
Next

Attribution:

Entries under this journal are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International license.

© 2026

Martin E. Segal Theatre Center, The CUNY Graduate Center

365 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10016-4309 | ph: 212-817-1860 | mestc@gc.cuny.edu

Untitled design (7).jpg
bottom of page