When the Circle Calls
By
Siobhan Juanita Brown
Published:
November 11, 2026

Abstract
After being invited by my community to serve as director for the original play, We Are the Land, I joined a circle of Wampanoag artists, leaders, activists, and historians to begin a devising process that would challenge all of the hierarchical practices and principles I’ve been taught in American Theater.
Mâsseepee (Mashpee) is Wôpanâak land. We are People of the First Light, People of the Dawn. Alongside other tribes in the Northeast, we are often referred to as those who have experienced First Contact with non-Native people. We are the nation most aligned with the stories of lost pilgrims and turkey feasts. Here in Mashpee we simply say âs nutâyuneân - we still live here. We have to repeat saying this in many different ways - repeat and revise. Because the systemic theft of our homelands and the transformation of them into a vacation hot spot after 400 years of colonial occupation is an ever present call to action. This call gets especially loud over the fireworks, flags in the wind and praise hyping of annual and commemoration events.
The Plymouth 400 and America250 have origins right here in Wampanoag Country. Indigenous artists feel the pulse quicken during the fall, especially in “Native November” when every school, church group, museum, theater and library seek to focus their programs on “our local Indigenous tribes who are right here.” Apparently we aren’t important enough to feature in March or June. Particularly in the Northeast where the first sign of fall foliage starts to ignite the desire for Wampanoag programming. New England. Massachusetts. Boston - the “Athens of America” - where in 1675, two or more Wampanoag people were considered a "barbarous crew” if found walking in Boston Common and could be arrested for sedition. The Indian Imprisonment Act of 1675 was the General Court’s response to King Philip’s War and was not repealed until 2005. After nearly forty years of a peace treaty implemented by Wampanoag leader Massasoit, his second son Metacom is raised as leader to respond to the rise in treaty violations by colonists in Wampanoag Territory. The fourteen month war with the New England Confederation halts and in some cases removes the development of towns and villages stealing Wampanoag lands. Over forty percent of the tribe is killed and many are sold into slavery. Repeat and revise. Because we have been here for over 10,000 years. Our stories are embedded in the land and glimpses of these stories can be found in the etymology of our language. When we say the word for ‘our land’ it translates to our inseparable connection to the land - we are the land and the land is us.
When the plans started for the Plymouth 400 to commemorate the voyage and arrival of the Mayflower on Wampanoag shores, no one would have ever thought that the irony of a current day global pandemic canceling those plans would mirror that of The Great Dying. In the early 1600’s, an epidemic of disease brought by colonizers spread from Maine to Narragansett Bay. That pandemic caused the death of 75% to 90% of Wampanoag People along the eastern coast of our territory which was home to over 69 Wampanoag tribes.
The original commemoration plans included the development of a production in collaboration with the Theatre Royal Plymouth (TRP), in the UK. This production would provide the Wampanoag perspective of the Plymouth 400. There were zoom calls, in person meetings with European theater folk traveling to Mashpee to introduce themselves, take pictures, record nature sounds, share meals, and figure out a way to put on a play in the spring of 2020.
In their well-meaning way, TRP hired a playwright to write a script and hired actors to help train the Wampanoag tribal members who did not have any acting experience. However, through this exchange, it was clear that history was repeating itself through their colonized process for this project. And our Wampanoag elders came together in the circle with the well-meaning TRP team and let them know just that. That we are a tribe of storytellers, artisans and writers. That we have a voice and that we could write and tell our own story.
The idea of coming together to put on a play may have seemed out of touch with what was happening in our tribe and our communities at that time. The impact of the pandemic on our community was multifaceted, largely due to the Trump administration trying to attack our sovereignty and dis-establish us as a tribe less than two weeks after the start of the quarantine. Despite being known as ‘the tribe who met the pilgrims’, and a tribe with a large corpus of historical written documents, our tribe was not recognized by the federal government until 2007. Again, and this time over zoom and social media, we fought back with the support of Indian Country and won our case. Our federal recognition was protected. Âs nutâyuneân. Repeat and revise.
In retrospect, it was fitting that, during this low time, our pathway forward was one of creating art rooted in identity, empowerment and the truth of our history. We connected with the TRP community again and this time, they wanted to “do it right”. They shifted from holding space with privilege, power and creative control over the play to a position of listening. Listening for ways to support our process in creating a production from our voices and traditions. After this shift, many ideas began to come to the surface for the play. Some ideas were very grand, very expensive, while some were subtle touches that really lifted the piece to a place of the beauty of the past despite knowing what was yet to come. Early conversations with TRP involved having over 100 tribal members involved, in order to have a spectacle of numbers. But after the shift and move toward collaborative listening, a smaller cast was agreed on for the devising and writing process. The possibilities were coming to the surface through mutual respect and a sense of community was growing that spoke to the national call of the time during the summer of 2020: “show me what democracy looks like.”
And then, the circle called. And it was a powerful circle of historians, artists, songkeepers, dancers, and storytellers. A circle with no beginning and no end, rooted in our tradition of continuity and balance. It was at this time that I was voluntold to be involved. One can freely volunteer for activities of their choosing, but when the Aunties, Uncles and cousins volunteer you for something…you’ve been voluntold. And I will be forever grateful and humbled that I was even thought of in this circumstance. There were fourteen beautiful Wampanoag actors and one fierce Nipmuc actor - representing our King Phillip’s War allies! I served as director for the Yet to Be Named Production. We gathered over the course of about a year to strengthen our circle, devise the script and rehearse it before traveling to England. Wampanoag Artist and Writer Hartman Deetz provided a solid framework that included several points in Wampanoag history to explore as a storyline. Our Wampanoag 10,000 vs. the Plymouth 400. We decided to approach the play as we approach our daily lives: with one foot in our history and traditions and another foot in our contemporary lives. Balancing our conscious awareness of the sacrifices of Massasoit and Metacom so that we can be here today, our whole selves, as Wampanoag people, living in the modern world on our ancestral homelands.
We opened the play with pre-contact times of storytelling involving the beloved Maushop, a giant who cared deeply for us and shared warnings of prophecies of a complex and dangerous future. The play moved through times of significant historical impact on our people. Ironically, the physical arrival of the Mayflower played a very small role in this production. Focus was centered on the spiritual warfare on our people. The impacts of forced Christianization and assimilation took center stage in the first half of the play. Staying close to our Mashpee roots, we touched on the leadership of Weetumuw, a woman chief who led hundreds of men in battle during King Phillip’s War. Her interactions with John Sassamon, a Christianized Wampanoag playing both sides of the war in support of the colonizers, set the tone for an all encompassing impact of our history - women leaders, confounding the english, fighting in war time, grappling with assimilation, religion and upholding Wampanoag identity and cosmology in an everchanging environment.
From 1675, we move to the Woodlot Riot of 1833 when Mashpee Wampanoag minister Blind Joe Amos (played by his descendant) and Pequot minister William Apess struggled to reconcile the unity principles found in the Bible with their lived experiences. They found these principles were not matching their experience as Christian ministers forced to preach to their Indigenous parishioners outside of the church, while their white counterparts “warmed themselves inside the pews.” The Woodlot Riot was inspired by the theft of wood and other natural resources from Wampanoag land taken by colonizers seeking to enrich themselves by selling those resources back to Wampanoag people on their homelands.
Throughout the play we hear from our elders and their lifelong work to reclaim land, right the many wrongs put on us and to set up the next generation for success in a contemporary world. Historians and published authors Linda Coombs and Paula Peters alongside culture bearers Gertrude Kitty Hendricks and Carol Wynne brought a wealth of knowledge and experience. Commissioner on Indian Affairs for the State of Massachusetts, Jim Peters shared memories of a Mashpee that held “just us, all our relations, living on Mother Earth”. Our Mashpee changed to lands besieged by over development and gated communities in a short period of time.
Our rehearsal process was often spent sitting around the table and listening to the wisdom of experiences of everyone in the circle. These Listening Sessions wrote the script. With each historical topic came a relative contemporary experience. This circle process of allowing space for all of the voices in the circle to be heard, reflects our traditional peacemaking ways. The age range was as young as 11 years old and went to a high elder status. (You are not getting me in trouble, I am not telling the eldest age in the group. Let’s just say that every decade in between was represented well beyond senior discount status.) With this diversity in age, we quickly embraced a set of values to work from including mutual respect, honesty, trust and love. This is not to say that we did not have challenges in this process. When conflict happened, we returned to the circle to clarify the root cause of our differences in order to come to a deeper understanding of one another. This was where the true work of storytelling happened. Listening to the motives or expectations of group members with regard to this project was a necessary component to reaching as much alignment to our overall purpose as possible. This exploration, this seeking alignment, took time, challenging conversations and moments of sitting with discomfort. Some members were very concerned about performing this play in front of a majority white audience. And this reality was very triggering for some members. Will they get it? Will they truly understand our message? This trepidation of the unknown was where I relied heavily on my training and lived experience as a theater artist. With the intent of connecting with those feelings, I shared about personal experiences working in theater in this country. The long hours. The low pay. The hierarchical nature of the rehearsal process of having a top down cycle of power as opposed to a shared power and responsibility for the script and the storytelling. I shared about my own training and how it actively erased our culture by having no teachers of color in my program. Most of the plays included in my training were from Europe; not once did I work on a play by an Indigenous writer. And now, this play has fifteen Indigenous writers. It was a new, meaningful and humbling journey that we were on together. Most importantly, I reminded them that the answers to those important questions about cohesion and clarity were here in our circle. The talent to unify ourselves in our purpose to tell our story in this way was ancestral. This process was simply calling that talent forward, in each one of us.
Our story development continued. After the Woodlot Riot of 1833 the story moved to the 1900’s. Vanessa Mendes shared her experience of trying to apply for a home loan in the 1970’s before being confronted with a requirement to purchase deed insurance essentially against herself. “You don’t want the tribe to take your land, do you?” Her experience was one of shock and sadness that this unjust practice was continuously monetized and required her to participate in her own erasure as a Wampanoag citizen on Wampanoag lands. This scene flowed to our courtroom fight to rescue and preserve our homelands here in Mashpee and in the surrounding lands of Cape Cod.
In 1976, the Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe filed a lawsuit against the town of Mashpee for the return of our homelands - 11,000 acres which were preserved for us by our ancestors in perpetuity. Our last historical scene called in the lived experience of our cast members. Jim Peters was present in the courtroom for this case and shared his recollection. With the truth of our history on trial, Jim recalled hearing a harrowing message from the judge after delivering the verdict saying that we could be a tribe for all purposes except the return of our land; the consequences are too great.1
Our circle sessions were my favorite part of this process. They shaped every scene, every staged moment. Before the script existed, we talked with one another. Shared stories. Inspired one another. The fear that the audience wouldn’t understand it all, particularly those overseas who do not live here and know nothing about us was assuaged. It was in those moments where everyone put in the work, moved through fear and doubt and made a collective space for imaginative dreaming.
At the center of that work was the decolonization of the theater-making process. With any creative endeavor, there are expectations; often unspoken. As a holder of the rehearsal space, I took each opportunity to internally interrogate and challenge all that I had been taught in the predominantly white institution that trained me in theater. I questioned everything. Our creative circling changed my approach to making theater, telling stories and community devising. Whether we embrace it as such or not, leadership is a shared responsibility that is informed by the circle. The wisdom in the rehearsal room, in the circle, was often overwhelming. I came face to face with all that I did not know about our history, culture and lifeways. I had to give myself grace, daily, for all that I did not know. That knowledge gap was by design. The colonial construct of white supremacy culture was not only embedded in my early education, it was also in my theater training as an adult. I found joy and not dissonance in stepping up and stepping back, speaking and listening, and above all, learning. Decolonizing theater is a practice steeped in love for the artform and grace for the layering of corporate mindset over the tender creative hold of cultural identity often denied in the growth of a young Black and Wampanoag artist like myself. Repeat and revise because âs nutâyuneân, we are still here.
“But how do we end the play?” This question lingered for quite some time. Again, we went to the circle. And it came to the surface - what if we just did what we are doing right now?
During the production in Plymouth, UK, there was a silence I will never forget. Each scene brought the audience through the experience of life as a Wampanoag person with this history moving through our DNA. We Are The Land ended with each actor standing center stage and telling their personal connection to our history, our families, our land, our language and our tribe. We started with the eldest and ended with the youngest. The final scene mirrors the opening scene, centering joy and grounded Indigeneity, giving the sense of life as a Wampanoag person carrying this history each day, wherever we go. The circle holds us. The circle created this play. When the circle calls, we have to answer to the best of our ability.
Otter Clan Mother, Carol Wynne shares in her final monologue that: “I believe our Creator gave us our first breath of life at birth, and with that he also gave us a spirit; our first thought, our reason for life and it grows with us constantly. That is this: We are to live off the land and protect it for the next seven generations. That’s all we have to do, each generation.”
When the circle calls, it is a call to do what we can to restore balance within ourselves and our communities. Our collective responsibility to approach this commemoration with radical truth through the art of storytelling has reinforced my reason for life and healed my connection to my beloved artform. Repeat and revise. Âs nutâyuneân. We still live here. And we will always be here.
-
Image Credits:
Note
[1] Jim Peters, Verbal message at rehearsal, November 20, 2022.
About the author(s)
Siobhan Juanita Brown is from Roxbury, MA and is a member of the Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe. She lives in Mashpee and is a loving partner, daughter, sister, auntie, friend and storyteller. With the Wôpanâak Language Reclamation Project she was a language apprentice and teacher at Weetumuw Katnuhtôhtâeekamuq, the first Wôpanâak language and culture school providing academic and Indigenous education using a Montessori pedagogy for decolonization and language reclamation. Siobhan has served as the Co – Indigenous Solidarity & Sovereignty Officer for the board of Montessori for Social Justice and Co - Chair of Representation, Equity and Diversity at the Kennedy Center American College Theatre Festival. She currently works for the Native Land Conservancy, an Indigenous led land conservation and is director of We Are The Land, a community devised play that shares historical and contemporary perspectives on the Wampanoag experience and our sacred relationship to the land.
Indigenous Stages

tah-kōx
INDIGENOUS STAGES is the first global forum and interdisciplinary academic journal primarily dedicated to Indigenous authors writing about the theatrical and cultural performance of Indigenous artists and communities from across the globe. This journal will be the first forum ever for the diverse range of Indigenous scholarship and cultural performance practices not only to be shared among Indigenous communities but also to be published in English, or in the respective Indigenous languages with an English translation.
Published by The Martin E. Segal Theatre Center at The Graduate Center at CUNY, the mission of INDIGENOUS STAGES is to foster, survey, and publish the contemporary and historical theoretical discourse surrounding the field. Peer-reviewed articles as well as critical book and performance reviews will contribute to further strengthen Indigenous studies as an academic discipline within theatre and performance studies. INDIGENOUS STAGES will enable academics, students, artists, cultural practitioners, activists, and community members to research, discuss, and present their work in a unique forum—while creating and nurturing local, national, and global relationships within and between Indigenous communities and thereby fostering solidarity.
Published by The Martin E. Segal Theatre Center at The Graduate Center at CUNY, with additional support for the content of the inaugural edition provided by the Hawai'ian Theatre Program at the University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa.
Entries under this journal are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International license.


